Policy & law

Essays on AI regulation, executive orders, antitrust, copyright litigation and the definitions that decide what a rule covers.

Bit for Bit on a B300, Nothing on an H100

16 minute read

· Policy & law

A report published yesterday says six open-weight models from DeepSeek, Moonshot, MiniMax and Ant Group were initialized on Nvidia Blackwell chips that need a US license for China. The core of it is a rule in PyTorch’s random-number code that I could check myself, and a rerun that anyone can repeat on a laptop. The fingerprint is close to airtight for what it shows. The cluster sizes built on top of it are not, and the method only works until labs stop leaving the trace.

Every robots.txt on the Web Says Nothing Yet

16 minute read

· Policy & law

On 30 October an Anthropic engineer filed an IETF draft for a shared robots.txt token that says β€˜no AI training’, and Anthropic, OpenAI, Google and Microsoft said they would honor it. The draft is careful: no existing file expresses a preference, and wildcard rules never count. The vendors are less aligned. Their start dates run from β€˜already implementing’ to February 2027, and at Google a training opt-out lands on a control that also covers Gemini grounding.

Not Optional, and Not Defined: The White House Incident Order Meets Its Own Examples

19 minute read

· Policy & law

On 9 October the White House told AI companies that reporting incidents involving their models is β€˜not optional.’ It did not say what an incident is. I ran the two cases that prompted the statement, a fake police tip and twenty visa forms, through the AI incident definitions in the EU AI Act, California’s SB 53 and New York’s RAISE Act. Neither case qualifies under any of them. The one clause that came close was removed in March.

Nineteen Summaries and One Complaint

8 minute read

· Policy & law

USA Today Co. filed suit against OpenAI on 8 October 2026, claiming damages above $250 million. The complaint is shorter in its claims than the New York Times case was, and the evidence it documents most fully is a set of retrieval outputs, not the training data the headline is about.

A Watermark With a Miss Rate

15 minute read

· Policy & law

OpenAI is putting an invisible watermark in ChatGPT and Codex text in the EU, and it published detection numbers with the announcement. They are more candid than most vendor figures. They also show a watermark that, on psychology text, misses one 200-token passage in five and most of a 400-token passage with a quarter of its words swapped for synonyms.

Reliable, Not Genuine

12 minute read

· Policy & law

An Arizona appeals court vacated a manslaughter sentence this week because the sentencing judge relied on an AI video of the victim. The headlines say AI overturned a sentence. The opinion says something narrower, and more interesting: the video was unreliable, and the judge called it genuine.

An Expectation Is Not an Agreement

17 minute read

· Policy & law

Chegg and Penske Media told a federal judge that Google had broken an unwritten deal: content for traffic. The ruling that killed both lawsuits this week turns out to be the second time in six months the same judge has rejected the same theory from different publishers, in nearly the same words. The press called it β€˜no formal bargain.’ The judge’s own phrase was narrower and harder to argue with: an expectation is not an agreement.

OpenAI Worried About the Optics. The Authors’ Brief Leans on Something Else.

18 minute read

· Policy & law

The line from the unsealed authors’ filing that reached the top of Hacker News is a 2019 Slack message worrying that LibGen would look bad on Hacker News. It is vivid evidence that people knew. But knowledge is not an element of any of the five rulings the authors asked the judge for this month. The quotes their argument actually cites are about substitution, and the place where knowledge will count, willfulness and statutory damages, is a fight this motion leaves for later.

Anthropic Won Under β€˜Adversary’ and Lost Under β€˜Any Person’

16 minute read

· Policy & law

Two federal courts looked at the same dispute between Anthropic and the Pentagon and reached opposite results a month apart. Both agreed Anthropic had no bad motive. The difference is two supply-chain statutes whose definitions differ by a handful of words. The D.C. Circuit’s reading of the broader one, which it says holds β€˜at least as applied here,’ would reach any AI vendor whose model is trained to refuse.

Renaming AI β€˜Super Intelligence’ Changes No Definition in Force

15 minute read

· Policy & law

At the UN on 22 September the President said AI would hereinafter be called β€˜Super Intelligence’. The next day a Senate bill proposed making β€˜artificial superintelligence’ a federal crime. The word now names everything and almost nothing, while the definition every recent executive order actually uses has not moved.

Newsom’s Kill Switch Order Does Not Require a Kill Switch. It Requires a Memo by November 16.

16 minute read

· Policy & law

Executive Order N-9-26 asks California’s Government Operations Agency whether a frontier-model kill switch is feasible, and whether its efficacy could be β€˜verified on an ongoing basis.’ The answer is due in 59 days. The engineering field that has verified shutdown devices for decades has a method, and the method’s own worked examples show it missing between 20 and 80 percent of the failures it is meant to catch.

Ninety-Three Percent of What? The Times’ Case Against OpenAI, Read Before the Headlines

18 minute read

· Policy & law

The number everyone quoted from the unsealed New York Times filing, a 93% drop in click-through from Microsoft’s Copilot, was a blank space in the public brief two weeks ago. Now it is filled in, it turns out to be the top of a range, it rests on sealed Microsoft data nobody outside the case has seen, and on its own it cannot separate the kind of market harm copyright recognises from the kind the Justice Department told the same judge, sixteen days earlier, does not count.

Lina Khan Reached for a 1934 Candy Case. It Fits the AI Race Better Than the Handcuffs Do.

19 minute read

· Policy & law

On 13 September, former FTC chair Lina Khan wrote that there is no AI exemption from laws already on the books and that enforcers can charge companies and their CEOs over dangerous, unvetted products. Put against this summer’s agent incidents, the criminal route is the weakest part of that claim. The strongest part rests on FTC v. R.F. Keppel, a case about penny candy, and its remedy is an order, not an arrest.

Amodei Asked for a Narrow Antitrust Waiver. The One Already in Law Belongs to the President.

18 minute read

· Policy & law

Dario Amodei’s plan to pace the frontier has three steps, and the middle one rests on a footnote: rival labs should coordinate on slowing down only with Washington mediating or waiving antitrust restrictions. Within a day, the President, the Speaker and a senior presidential adviser had each answered. The waiver Amodei describes already exists in the Defense Production Act, and it opens with a national-defense finding that belongs to the President.

page 1 of 2 · 17 essays on Policy & law